A preppy store for average size people?

Is there a "preppy" store that sells shirts that fit normal size people. I am 5-7 and 205. The problem is that im a weightlifter and I have rather overdeveloped deltoid and tzius so nothing that Abercrombie and Fitch, Aeropostal, or American Eagle sell even comes close to fitting. Some of their shirts the arm hole is so small and they are cut so small at the top I can't even get them on without busting the seams. I bought a 2XL from aeropostal which is too long. I simply raised my arm to reach a shelf and it busted the shirt.